Breaking Ramadan Fasting With Intercourse: Rules on Kaffarat
Learn the Islamic rulings on breaking a Ramadan fast through prohibited intimate acts, whether ignorance of kaffarat is an excuse, and requirements.
This article was first published in Indonesian. Baca versi Bahasa Indonesia →
Question:
Someone asks about an incident roughly ten years ago, around the time he reached puberty, when he engaged in a homosexual act with another person during the daytime in Ramadan—we seek Allah's protection. At the time, neither of them knew about the obligation to pay kaffarat (expiation). Praise be to Allah, He granted both of them the opportunity to repent and remain steadfast. Some time later, they heard a fatwa by Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen on YouTube stating that their expiation is analogous to the kaffarat for sexual intercourse during the daytime in Ramadan.
The questions are:
-
Does the kaffarat apply to both of them?
-
Can ignorance regarding the kaffarat be taken into consideration in this matter?
-
Is penetration required for this ruling, given that they can no longer remember with certainty due to the passage of time?
Answer:
First, a fasting person must refrain from sexual intercourse during the daytime in Ramadan. If someone does this, kaffarat becomes obligatory upon them. It makes no difference whether the penetration occurs in the vagina or the anus, with a male or a female. If penetration occurs in the anus of a male, this constitutes a homosexual act, which is a major sin. The perpetrator has committed two grave sins: the sin of homosexuality and deliberately breaking the fast during the daytime in Ramadan. He must repent to Allah the Exalted, pay the kaffarat, and make up for the invalidated fast of that day. Because making up the missed fast has been delayed until today, in addition to replacing the broken fast, he is also obliged to feed a needy person with the measure of 1.5 kg of rice or its equivalent.
It is stated in Kitab al-Iqna' (1/312):
“If a person commits penetration during the daytime in Ramadan with his an-nasl (glans penis) into a woman—whether through the vagina or the anus, human or otherwise, living or dead, whether reaching orgasm or not—it is obligatory upon him to make up for his fast and pay the kaffarat.”
Kitab al-Iqna' (1/312)
Second, the kaffarat is obligatory upon both the active participant and the consenting partner.
Third, ignorance of the obligation to pay kaffarat does not cause that obligation to be waived. The fundamental principle in this matter is that whoever knows that an action is haram (unlawful), yet does not know the consequences of committing it, has no excuse. Similarly, the Companion of the Prophet who had relations with his wife during the daytime in Ramadan also did not know that he would incur the obligation to pay kaffarat. Yet that did not serve as an excuse to exempt him from the requirement of expiation.
Shaykh Ibn Uthaymeen (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
“Did the Companion who came to the Messenger of Allah ﷺ not know the ruling? The answer is that he did not know the consequence of his action, not that he was unaware that the act itself was unlawful. That is why he said, 'I am ruined.' And if we say that ignorance is an excuse, we do not mean ignorance of the consequence of this prohibited act. Rather, what is meant is ignorance of the ruling of the act itself; whether it is forbidden or not.”
Al-Sharh al-Mumti' (6/417)
(See: al-Sharh al-Mumti' 6/417)
Fourth, kaffarat is required when the hasyafah (glans) of the male organ penetrates into the woman's private part. The hasyafah refers to the head of the penis up to the circumcision line, also known as al-kamarah. Such penetration carries the exact legal consequence as complete sexual intercourse.
Ibn al-Qayyim (may Allah have mercy on him) stated:
“The circumcision of a man is the circular ridge below the tip of the penis. This is the part that triggers legal rulings when it enters entirely into a woman's private part. More than three hundred rulings are connected to the entry of this part into the farj (private part), and some have even counted up to three hundred and ninety-two rulings.”
Tuhfah al-Maudud bi Ahkam al-Maulud, p. 152
(See: Tuhfah al-Maudud bi Ahkam al-Maulud, p. 152)
If penetration with the head of the penis did not occur, or if there is doubt regarding it, then paying kaffarat is not obligatory, because religious obligations cannot be established on the basis of doubt. However, sincere repentance from the unlawful act remains mandatory.
And Allah knows best.








