Must You Make Up Fasts if Ramadan Dates Were Wrong?

What happens if authorities miscalculate the start of Ramadan? Learn the Islamic legal ruling on making up fasts when fewer than 29 days were completed.

Must You Make Up Fasts if Ramadan Dates Were Wrong?
Illustration of crescent moon sighting to determine the start of Ramadan

This article was first published in Indonesian. Baca versi Bahasa Indonesia →

Question

What are the consequences if the government or religious authorities make a mistake in determining the start and end of Ramadan, and it is later proven that we missed a day of fasting? Are we required to make up (qada') that fast, or what should be done?

Answer

Alhamdulillah (all praise is due to Allah). If it is established through valid Islamic legal methods (syar'i) that Muslims made an error in determining the start and end of Ramadan, they are obligated to make up (qada') any missed day of fasting that was not completed properly.

Read Also: Ramadan: The Month of the Qur'an

How Can Such an Error Occur?

An error in determining the beginning and end of Ramadan can be confirmed through recognized Islamic legal methods, including:

  1. Completing 30 days of Sha'ban based on an unconfirmed sighting – If people complete Sha'ban as 30 days, but later a trustworthy witness testifies that he had actually sighted the new moon (hilal) on the 29th night of Sha'ban and his testimony is accepted by a judge, this testimony provides grounds for correcting the calendar retroactively.

  2. Declaring Eid al-Fitr after only 28 days of fasting – If Muslims begin fasting Ramadan on a date that later turns out to have been mistaken, and they then sight the moon of Shawwal after having fasted only 28 days, they must make up one day of fasting to fulfill the required minimum length of the Islamic month.

The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ stated that a Hijri month can never be less than 29 days. If it is established that the start of Ramadan was calculated incorrectly and Muslims have only fasted 28 days when the Shawwal moon appears, one day of fasting must be made up.

Historical Precedents of Miscalculated Ramadan Dates

Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyyah recorded in Majmu' al-Fatawa (Vol. 25, pp. 154–155) that such a situation occurred during the caliphate of Ali bin Abi Thalib (may Allah be pleased with him). On that occasion, Muslims had fasted for only 28 days, so Ali instructed them to make up one day of fasting so that their total reached the Islamic minimum of 29 days.

A similar incident occurred in Saudi Arabia in 1404 AH (1984 CE). The Permanent Committee for Scholarly Research and Ifta in Saudi Arabia issued a ruling that Muslims must make up one day of fasting due to an error in determining the start of Ramadan (See: Fatawa al-Lajnah al-Da'imah, 10/122).

In that year, the Ramadan crescent was not verified on Wednesday night, so Saudi authorities instructed the public to complete Sha'ban as 30 days. However, the Shawwal moon was sighted on Thursday night (the eve of Friday), leading to Eid al-Fitr being declared for Friday. As a result, Muslims had only fasted for 28 days, which is invalid according to Islamic jurisprudence. Consequently, scholars ruled that they were obligated to make up one day of fasting to rectify the oversight.

What If the Correction Is Based Only on Astronomical Calculations (Hisab)?

If a correction to the start or end of Ramadan is not established through valid Islamic legal methods (such as verified moonsighting testimonies accepted by Islamic authorities), but is instead based solely on astronomical calculations (hisab) or personal assumptions, such a correction holds no weight under Islamic law and requires no make-up fasts.

Conclusion

If an error in determining the start of Ramadan is proven through valid Islamic legal means, Muslims must make up (qada') the missing fast. However, if the claim of an error relies solely on astronomical calculation without valid Islamic legal proof, there is no obligation to make up any fasts.

And Allah knows best.